FHIR CI-Build

This is the Continuous Integration Build of FHIR (will be incorrect/inconsistent at times).
See the Directory of published versions icon

Responsible Owner: Implementable Technology Specifications icon Work GroupStandards Status: Normative
W3C RDF icon

This page and the RDF Turtle forms are jointly maintained by the HL7 FHIR project -- especially the RDF subgroup icon of the ITS work group icon -- and the W3C Semantic Web Health Care and Life Sciences Interest Group icon.

FHIR resources can be represented as an RDF graph icon serialized in the Turtle format icon. The Turtle format is defined to assist the process of bridging between operational data exchange and formal knowledge processing systems. While the Turtle form offers a fully functional representation of FHIR resources, it has different operational characteristics from the JSON and XML representations, and would be used for different reasons. Systems focused on operational exchange of data would not usually choose to use Turtle.

This page describes:

The following Turtle prefixes are used in FHIR Turtle examples, the FHIR ontology, and the ShEx schema.

# These are typically used in FHIR Turtle data:
@prefix fhir:   <http://hl7.org/fhir/> .
@prefix xsd:    <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#> .
@prefix rdf:    <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
@prefix rdfs:   <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
@prefix owl:    <http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#> .
@prefix loinc:  <http://loinc.org/rdf/> . # For LOINC codes
@prefix sct:    <http://snomed.info/id/> . # For SNOMED-CT codes

# These are normally only used in the OWL ontology or ShEx schema:
@prefix fhirvs: <http://hl7.org/fhir/ValueSet/> .
@prefix fhirsd: <http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/> .
@prefix fhirw5: <http://hl7.org/fhir/w5#> .
@prefix dc:     <http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/> .

Each resource page has a set of language templates describing the FHIR expression in that language. The Turtle representation for a resource is described using this format:

[ a fhir:Observation;
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot;     # if this is the parser root
  # from Resource: fhir:id; fhir:meta; fhir:implicitRules; and fhir:language
  # from DomainResource: fhir:text; fhir:contained; fhir:extension; and fhir:modifierExtension
  fhir:identifier ( [ Identifier ] ... ) ;  # 0..* Business Identifier for observation
  fhir:status [ code ]; # 1..1 registered | preliminary | final | amended ...
  fhir:code [ CodeableConcept ];   # 1..1 Type of observation (code / type)
  fhir:subject [ Reference(BiologicallyDerivedProduct|Device|Group...) ]; # 0..1 Who and/or what this is about
  fhir:encounter [ Reference(Encounter) ]; # 0..1 Healthcare event during which this observation is made
  # effective[x]: 0..1 Clinically relevant time/time-period for observation. One of these 4:
    fhir:effective [ a fhir:DateTime ; dateTime ];
    fhir:effective [ a fhir:Period ; Period ];
    fhir:effective [ a fhir:Timing ; Timing ];
    fhir:effective [ a fhir:Instant ; instant ];
  ...
]

Using this format:

  • To build a valid Turtle instance of a resource, replace the contents of the property values with valid content as described by the type rules and content description found in the property value for each element.
  • Nodes are never empty. If an element is present in the resource, it SHALL have properties as defined for its type, or 1 or more extensions.
  • 0..1 indicates an OPTIONAL element, i.e., minimum cardinality 0 and maximum cardinality 1. Similarly 1..1 indicates a required element.
  • 0..* or 1..* indicates an OPTIONAL or REQUIRED element (respectively) with no maximum cardinality.
  • Any element that allows more than one value is represented as an RDF list (see below). If an RDF list is provided, it SHALL NOT be empty.
  • Content type shown as Reference(BiologicallyDerivedProduct|Device|Group...) means that it must be a Reference to a BiologicallyDerivedProduct, or a Device, or a Group, etc.
  • # effective[x] indicates a polymorphic property (see below), whose value (in this example) may be a fhir:DateTime, fhir:Period, fhir:Timing or fhir:Instant.

Note that examples in this specification show Turtle that is nicely formatted and well laid out, but that is not required or expected in conforming FHIR Turtle.

An example FHIR Turtle Observation illustrates the Turtle language and the additional conventions used by FHIR Turtle:

                                  # bgpanel has type fhir:Observation
<http://hl7.org/fhir/Observation/bgpanel> a fhir:Observation ;
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot ;   # and is the root of this document.
  fhir:id [ fhir:v "bgpanel"] ;   # Its id is bgpanel.
  fhir:status [ fhir:v "final"] ; # It has an (extensible) status of final.
  fhir:code [                     # It has code,
     fhir:coding ( [              # given by a list of Codings,
       a loinc:34532-2 ;          # each having an OPTIONAL concept IRI (see below)
       fhir:system [              # plus a code system URI
         fhir:l <http://loinc.org> ;               # (as an OPTIONAL RDF node,
         fhir:v "http://loinc.org"^^xsd:anyURI ] ; # but always as a literal),
                                  # and a code:
       fhir:code [ fhir:v "34532-2" ]
     ] )
  ] ;
  fhir:subject [
     fhir:l <http://hl7.org/fhir/Patient/infant> ;
     fhir:reference [ fhir:v "Patient/infant" ]
  ] ; #
  …

In this example,

  • the subject IRI icon is wrapped with '< ... >',
  • the type (fhir:Observation) and following properties (e.g. fhir:status) are prefixed names (like XML namespaced names),
  • assertions following a ';' re-use the same subject,
  • anonymous nodes are declared with '[ ... ]'s,
  • and literals with a quoted value and an optional datatype preceded by '^^' (e.g. "http://loinc.org"^^xsd:anyURI).

FHIR Turtle imposes additional conventions to simplify recognition and manipulation of FHIR RDF graphs.  Although RDF graphs in general may be serialized in any RDF format, FHIR RDF mandates support specifically for Turtle icon. All FHIR RDF documentation is expressed in Turtle.   And while the standard media type for Turtle is text/turtle, the use of Turtle for FHIR RDF uses the specialized media type application/fhir+turtle.

FHIR uses Shape Expressions (ShEx) icon to help define and validate FHIR RDF. See fhir.shex for the complete FHIR RDF schema. Each Resource page includes a link for the subset of fhir.shex needed to describe that Resource. The media type for ShEx is text/shex.

Each resource is represented as a set of RDF triples. When a resource has a persistent identity (e.g. it can be found at a particular URL -- usually a FHIR RESTful server), then that URL is its identity. Resources with no persistent identity (e.g. bundles from search results) have the identity of the root document -- "<>" in Turtle syntax. In the above example, the resource is the subject: <http://example.org/fhir/Observation/bgpanel>.

Some resources can contain other resources. Given that the relationships can appear in any order in RDF, it cannot be assumed that the first encountered element represents the resource of interest that is being represented by the set of Turtle statements. The focal resource -- the Resource that is not contained in any other Resource -- is indicated by having a fhir:nodeRole property with a value of fhir:treeRoot. If there is more than one node labeled as a 'treeRoot' in a set of Turtle statements, it may be impossible to deterimine which is the outermost Resource.

Content within a resource is normally represented with anonymous nodes (a/k/a "blank nodes"), unless something else needs to reference that content.  Normally only FHIR Resource nodes are IRIs icon. For example, this Turtle:

          <http://example.org/fhir/Observation/bgpanel> fhir:status [ fhir:v "final" ]
          

asserts that:

  • <http://example.org/fhir/Observation/bgpanel> has a status of some anonymous node.
  • That anonymous node has a value of "final" (a literal), indicated by the fhir:v property. (See Primitive Elements below.)

Property names in FHIR RDF are shared across resources: the same property may be used in several different resources. For example, fhir:status is spelled the same way regardless of whether it appears in an Observation, Diagnosis, or any other FHIR Resource.

Some properties are polymorphic within a resource: the property may offer a choice of more than one permissible object type. If the Structure tab in a resource's HTML page shows "[x]" next to a property, such as value[x], then that property is polymorphic in FHIR RDF. (Alternatively, if the type property in the resource's structure definition shows a list of two or more types for a given property's value, then the property is polymorphic in FHIR RDF. For example, see the value property in Observation's JSON structure definition.) In other formats (XML, JSON), a FHIR property with a choice of value types has the type appended to the property name, e.g. valueQuantity if the value is a Quantity (i.e., Observation.valueQuantity). But in FHIR RDF, it is written as a polymorphic fhir:value property, and the object asserts its type explicitly, as shown in the following excerpt from an Observation body weight example. Confusingly, this excerpt happens to include a second (nested) fhir:value property, which is a property of the Quantity datatype (i.e., Quantity.value), and whose type is indicated directly by the xsd:decimal datatype attached to its fhir:v literal value.

  fhir:value [  # From Observation.value[x] (Observation.valueQuantity)
     a fhir:Quantity ;
     fhir:value [ fhir:v "185"^^xsd:decimal ] ;   # From Quantity.value
     fhir:unit [ fhir:v "lbs" ] ;
     fhir:system [ fhir:l <http://unitsofmeasure.org> ;
                   fhir:v "http://unitsofmeasure.org"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
     fhir:code [ fhir:v "[lb_av]" ]
  ] ;

While RDF property names are case-sensitive, FHIR avoids confusion by assuring that there are no properties that differ only in case.

Elements that can repeat are represented with RDF lists icon (officially called "RDF collections") in order to retain the order of their elements. For example this fhir:coding property holds a list of two members:

    fhir:coding (
      [ a <http://loinc.org/rdf/29463-7> … ]
      [ a <http://loinc.org/rdf/3141-9> … ]
    )

Since RDF lists can cause problems for OWL users, a script icon can convert RDF lists to an alternate representation. See Using FHIR RDF with OWL for more info.

Primitive elements -- elements with a primitive type -- are represented as anonymous nodes, both so that extensions can be attached and so that they can be consistently treated as OWL object properties (versus sometimes being datatype properties). Inside the anonymous node:

  • The FHIR datatype MUST be asserted using rdf:type (or a in Turtle shorthand) if it is not implied by the property whose value is being represented. See Property Names and Polymorphism for more explanation.
  • The name of each FHIR primitive type, such as code, is capitalized when written as an RDF class name: fhir:Code . This is done to avoid having a name clash with the fhir:code property, since RDF is case sensitive. For consistency, the RDF class name for the FHIR xhtml is also capitalized fhir:Xhtml even though it is technically a special type. All other FHIR RDF names use the same capitalization conventions as in the FHIR content model, JSON and XML.
  • Each FHIR type is represented by a particular XML Schema Datatype (XSD) icon, written with an xsd: or xs: prefix, or an RDF datatype.
  • The value of the primitive type is written as an RDF Literal using the fhir:v property, which is the only FHIR property that directly holds an RDF literal -- i.e., it is the only OWL datatype property in FHIR RDF -- and it always holds an RDF Literal.
  • A fhir:v literal has two parts: a quoted string that contains the value, and an XSD or RDF type:
      fhir:v "[value]"^^xsd:type

    The XSD type is one of the following XML Schema Datatypes (XSD) icon, typically written with an xsd: or xs: prefix: boolean icon, integer icon, decimal icon, base64Binary icon, dateTime icon, date icon, gYear icon, gYearMonth icon or time icon. RDF type rdf:XMLLiteral is used for values of FHIR type xhtml.

For example, a value of FHIR type positiveInt is an anonymous node with a fhir:v assertion and possibly a type assertion, like one of the following:

    [ fhir:v "2"^^xsd:positiveInteger ]                       # With implied FHIR type
    [ a fhir:PositiveInt ; fhir:v "2"^^xsd:positiveInteger ]  # With explicit FHIR type

The fhir:v property can never be empty. Either the relationship is absent, or it is present with at least one character of content. XHTML is represented as an escaped xsd:string. 

Some FHIR primitive datatypes are defined as a union of multiple XML Schema datatypes:

  • FHIR date (union of xsd:date, xsd:gYearMonth, xsd:gYear);
  • FHIR dateTime (union of xsd:dateTime, xsd:date, xsd:gYearMonth, xsd:gYear); and
  • FHIR decimal (union of xsd:decimal, xsd:double).

In such cases, the correct XSD type must be determined by inspecting the literal value for conformance with one of the union XSD types for that FHIR type. For example, since a FHIR decimal is a union of xsd:decimal icon and xsd:double icon, any value with an 'e' or 'E' in it is an xsd:double, otherwise it is an xsd:decimal. For example, for a property whose value is a FHIR decimal, an literal value of "185" must be given the XSD datatype xsd:decimal because it does not contain 'e' or 'E'. Values of other FHIR union types -- date or dateTime must be handled similarly, to assign the most specific XSD type that matches the given literal value.

Literal values that can be represented using Turtle shorthand notation for xsd:string, xsd:integer, xsd:decimal, xsd:double or xsd:boolean MAY optionally use shorthand instead of the long form described above. However, authors of FHIR Turtle serializers are advised to be aware that there are some differences between what is permitted in FHIR, Turtle shorthand, and XSD literals, and these differences can affect Turtle serialization of FHIR. For example:

  • The FHIR decimal datatype is represented by xsd:decimal icon in Turtle. Turtle shorthand for an xsd:decimal value requires a decimal point, whereas the xsd:decimal type does not. Therefore, a FHIR decimal value of 185 must either have a decimal point explicitly added, like 185.0, or the type must be explicitly indicated, like "185"^^xsd:decimal. Otherwise 185 in Turtle would be parsed as an xsd:integer.
  • Neither the FHIR boolean datatype nor the Turtle shorthand for an xsd:boolean allows a literal value of 0 or 1, though xsd:boolean icon does.

To facilitate linkage in RDF graphs, if a primitive has FHIR type uri or one of its subtypes (url, canonical, uuid, oid), then a fhir:l property -- previously called fhir:link, in FHIR R5 -- is RECOMMENDED as a sibling of the fhir:v property. The value of the fhir:l property is an RDF node having the same URI as the URI given in the fhir:v property, with one exception. If the fhir:v URI contains a vertical bar ("|", aka pipe symbol) then it represents a version indicator, which is stripped off and converted into a "?version=" query string, like this:

<http://example.org/fhir/MeasureReport/measurereport-cms146-cat3-example> fhir:measure [
      a fhir:Canonical ;
       fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/Measure/CMS146?version=v123> ;
       fhir:v "http://example.org/fhir/Measure/CMS146|v123"^^xsd:anyURI ;
    ] ;
          

A Reference element is represented using the same rules as above:

  fhir:subject [
     # a fhir:Reference ;
     fhir:reference [ fhir:v "Patient/example" ];
     fhir:display [ fhir:v "Example Patient" ];
  ];

This allows faithful round tripping of the resource between the Turtle format and the JSON and XML formats. However, it's very useful for an RDF processor if the RDF graph links to the target of the reference directly. This can be represented using the OPTIONAL fhir:l property:

  fhir:subject [
     # a fhir:Reference ;
     fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/Patient/example> ;
     fhir:reference [ fhir:v "Patient/example" ];
     fhir:display [ fhir:v "Example Patient" ];
  ];

The correct value for the fhir:l relationship must be determined by resolving the rules for resolving references, for the various reference types, to a literal URL that refers to the correct content in the local RDF context. Although the target type of the fhir:reference property is specified as xsd:string, it is required to be an absolute or relative URI or fragment identifier, so it can always be used for a fhir:l link.

The fhir:l relationship can be added automatically as part of generating the resource representation, or it can be injected by a post-processor that knows how to convert the raw references into RDF-suitable references.

Inline resources -- when a resource is contained directly in another element -- occur in the following places:

The following example (derived from this example) shows a Bundle. The Bundle holds a list of fhir:entrys, each of which specifies a Resource that is a member of that Bundle. Although Turtle serializes each Resource separately, they are logically all part of the same Bundle.

# This is the parent Bundle resource:
<http://hl7.org/fhir/Bundle/bundle-references> a fhir:Bundle ;
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot ;
  fhir:id [ fhir:v "bundle-references"] ;
  fhir:type [ fhir:v "collection"] ;
  fhir:entry ( [
      fhir:fullUrl [
        fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/Patient/23> ;
        fhir:v "http://example.org/fhir/Patient/23"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
      fhir:resource <http://example.org/fhir/Patient/23>
    ] )
…
# This is a member of the above Bundle:
<http://example.org/fhir/Patient/23> a fhir:Patient ;
  fhir:id [ fhir:v "23"] ;
  fhir:text [
     fhir:status [ fhir:v "generated" ] ;
     fhir:div [ fhir:v "…"^^rdf:XMLLiteral ]
  ] ;
  fhir:identifier ( [
     fhir:system [
       fhir:l <http://example.org/ids> ;
       fhir:v "http://example.org/ids"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
     fhir:value [ fhir:v "1234567" ]
  ] ) .

Except for transactions and batches, each entry in a Bundle has a URI that is determined from its fhir:fullUrl property as described in Resolving references in Bundles. Systems are responsible for ensuring a unique mapping from fullUrl to Resource, including in the case of multiple versions of a resource.

When parsed into RDF, all URIs are absolute, e.g. http://example.org/some/path.ext. The Turtle syntax for RDF leverages the same relative URL resolution icon as HTML. The FHIR examples (available from the downloads page) and this document follow some conventions described below with the goal of

  • illustrating the process of relative URL resolution,
  • leveraging the uniqueness of the identifiers afforded by Web architecture,
  • presenting terse and readable examples.

URLs are constructed from the fhir:id property if it is given in the example. These are presumed to be Resources in a server compliant with the FHIR REST API served from http://example.org/. Thusly, a PlanDefinition with id "KDN5" is assumed to have a URL of http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5.

If a contained resource has a fhir:id property, then its value MAY be used in generating a URI for that contained resource, following rules for Contained Resources. Local references (i.e., starting with "#") are relative to the parent (containing) resource. If the example does not include a containing Resource with an apparent URL, we will represent that resource's URI in Turtle as a relative URI.

In the following example (derived from the KDN5 example), the FHIR id is given ("KDN5") so we assume a base URL of http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5. The contained resource (having fhir:id "1111") is given a URL relative to that base. As in HTML, a "#" character is prepended to the child's fhir:id when it is used as a local reference. Given the asssumed base, the contained ActivityDefintion and the fhir:l and fhir:contained properties which reference it could be written as <#1111> but they are resolved here to their absolute URI, <http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5#1111> for clarity:

# KDN5 is the parent resource in this example:
<http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5> a fhir:PlanDefinition ; # Known URI
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot ;
  fhir:id [ fhir:v "KDN5"] ;
  # fhir:contained gives a list of resources that are logically contained
  # inside this (KDN5) resource, though Turtle serializes them separately:
fhir:contained ( <http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5#1111> ) ; # assertion of containership
  fhir:action ( [
    fhir:textEquivalent [ fhir:v "Gemcitabine 1250 mg/m² IV over 30 minutes on days 1 and 8" ] ;
    fhir:definition [
      a fhir:Canonical ;
      # Here the KDN5 parent references the contained resource:
fhir:l <http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5#1111> ; # use of the contained Resource
      fhir:v "#1111"^^xsd:anyURI ;     # Local reference starts with "#"
    ]
  ] ) ;
…
# The definition of the (logically) contained resource #1111 is here:
<http://example.org/PlanDefinition/KDN5#1111> a fhir:ActivityDefinition ;
     fhir:id [ fhir:v "1111" ] ;   # Local identifier
     fhir:status [ fhir:v "draft" ] .
…

In contrast, in the following example, the parent does not have an id so we would need information to know how this Resource is uniquely addressed. In the absense of that information, we will simply express the contained Resource as a relative URL, <#2222>, with an unstated base.

# KDN5 is the parent resource in this example:
<> a fhir:PlanDefinition ; # URI is relative to unspecified base URI
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot ;
  # fhir:contained gives a list of resources that are logically contained
  # inside this (KDN5) resource, though Turtle serializes them separately:
fhir:contained ( <#2222> ) ; # Relative URI
  fhir:action ( [
    fhir:textEquivalent [ fhir:v "Gemcitabine 1250 mg/m² IV over 30 minutes on days 1 and 8" ] ;
    fhir:definition [
      a fhir:Canonical ;
      # Here the KDN5 parent references the contained resource:
      fhir:l <#2222> ;
      fhir:v "#2222"^^xsd:anyURI ;     # Local reference starts with "#"
    ]
  ] ) ;
…
# The body of the (logically) contained resource 2222 is here, and receives
# a URI derived from its parent's URI:
<#2222> a fhir:ActivityDefinition ;
     fhir:id [ fhir:v "2222" ] ;   # Local identifier
     fhir:status [ fhir:v "draft" ] .
…

The same logic applies to the Coding data type. These are represented directly in Turtle by serializing their properties as above. However, for reasoners using the RDF graph, it's also useful to make the implicit concept references in these Codings explicit, by specifying an OPTIONAL concept IRI icon in an rdf:type assertion, written using shorthand a in Turtle:

fhir:code [
    fhir:coding (
        [
            a loinc:29463-7;    # OPTIONAL, but RECOMMENDED
            fhir:system [ fhir:v "http://loinc.org" ];
            fhir:code [ fhir:v "29463-7" ];
            fhir:display [ fhir:v "Body Weight" ]
        ]
        [
            a sct:27113001;    # OPTIONAL, but RECOMMENDED
            fhir:system [ fhir:v "http://snomed.info/sct" ];
            fhir:code [ fhir:v "27113001" ];
            fhir:display [ fhir:v "Body weight" ]
        ]
    )
];

A concept IRI icon uniquely identifies a concept that would otherwise be identified by a <Coding.system, Coding.code> pair. A concept IRI normally has two parts -- an IRI stem and a code -- though concept IRIs that do not follow this pattern can be used.

An IRI stem is the initial substring of the concept IRIs that correspond to all codes in a particular Code System or terminology. The concept IRI is formed by concatenating the IRI stem with the code (after percent-encoding any reserved characters -- see Appendix 1: Algorithm for Creating a Concept IRI for details). The IRI stem is typically used to define an IRI prefix in Turtle and SPARQL, such as loinc: or sct: in the above example. This approach allows the Compact URI loinc:29463-7 (in Turtle or SPARQL) to be easily translated into the concept IRI http://loinc.org/rdf/29463-7 by concatenating the IRI stem http://loinc.org/rdf/ with the code 29463-7. This particular IRI stem is defined in the LOINC User Guide S12.7.2 icon.

Compact URIs ("CURIEs") icon provide a mechanism for abbreviating IRIs using a prefix and a reference, separated by a colon, such as loinc:29463-7. Although some RDF systems have treated CURIEs directly as FHIR Codes -- i.e. including the "loinc:" prefix as part of the code -- non-prefixed FHIR codes like 29463-7 are strongly preferred because they align better with the use of IRI stems described herein. If the "loinc:" prefix were treated as part of the FHIR code, like loinc:29463-7, then when the IRI stem is prepended the resulting absolute IRI would become http://loinc.org/rdf/loinc:29463-7, which in this example would be incorrect for the intended LOINC concept.

One might wonder why the Coding.system is not used directly as the IRI stem for a given terminology. One reason is that Coding.systems often lack a convenient separator character as their final character, such as "/" or "#", which could cause problems if they were directly concatenated with codes, leading to erroneous concept IRIs such as http://loinc.org35217-9. But the main reason is that the Coding.system and the IRI stem of some terminologies were chosen independently and differ in unpredictable ways. Hence, there is no simple formula for determining the correct IRI stem from a Coding.system.

To address this problem, and to facilitate ease of use, HL7 maintains a mapping from Coding.systems to IRI stems: IRI stems can be registered and looked up in the HL7 Terminology (THO) website icon, based on the desired Coding.system. To look up the correct IRI stem for a given terminology, such as LOINC:

  1. navigate to the Table of Contents icon;
  2. search within the page for an appropriate link that includes "NamingSystem" in its URL, such as this one, for LOINC: https://terminology.hl7.org/NamingSystem-v3-loinc.html icon ; then
  3. scroll down to the Identifiers section icon, and look for the "IRI stem" entry: http://loinc.org/rdf/ .

If an IRI stem for a Coding.system is published at https://terminology.hl7.org/ icon it SHOULD be used. An NPM package is also available to efficiently automate lookup of IRI stems from Coding.systems. To add an IRI stem to that site, see Appendix 2: Registering an IRI Stem on the HL7 Terminology Website.

A Resource might have any number of non-modifier extensions, represented as an RDF list like this:

<http://example.org/fhir/MedicationRequest/MR321> a fhir:Observation;
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot;
  fhir:extension (
    [ fhir:url [
         fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/observation-bodyPosition> ;
         fhir:v "http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/observation-bodyPosition"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
      fhir:value [
        fhir:coding (
          a sct:33586001;
          fhir:system [ fhir:l <http://snomed.info/sct> ;
                        fhir:v "http://snomed.info/sct"^^xsd:anyURI ];
          fhir:code [ fhir:v "33586001" ];
          fhir:display [ fhir:v "Sitting position (finding)" ]
        ) ] ]
    [ fhir:url [
        fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/observation-delta> ;
        fhir:v "http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/observation-delta"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
      fhir:value [
        fhir:coding (
          a sct:1250004;
          fhir:system [ fhir:l <http://snomed.info/sct> ;
                        fhir:v "http://snomed.info/sct"^^xsd:anyURI ];
          fhir:code [ fhir:v "1250004" ];
          fhir:display [ fhir:v "Decreased (qualifier value)" ]
        ) ] ]
  )

A primitive element such as fhir:birthDate can have a list of extensions attached like this:

   …
     fhir:birthDate [
       fhir:v "2016-05-18"^^xsd:date ;
       fhir:extension ( [
         fhir:url [
           fhir:l <http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/patient-birthTime> ;
           fhir:v "http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/patient-birthTime"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
         fhir:value [
           a fhir:DateTime ;
           fhir:v "2016-05-18T10:28:45Z"^^xsd:dateTime
         ]
       ] )
     ]
          

See Extensibility for additional guidance on FHIR extensibility.

FHIR allows modifierExtensions on DomainResources, BackboneElements and BackboneTypes. The type of any DomainResource with any modifierExtension is prefixed with '_' in RDF. The '_' prefix helps prevent FHIR RDF processors that do not understand a particular modifier extension from blindly processing it as though it still had the original semantics.  The structure of the element is otherwise unchanged. Note the underscore at the beginning of "_MedicationRequest" in the following example:

<http://example.org/fhir/MedicationRequest/MR321> a fhir:_MedicationRequest;
  fhir:nodeRole fhir:treeRoot;
  fhir:extension ( ... );           # above bodyPosition and delta extensions
  fhir:modifierExtension (
    [
      fhir:url [
        fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/anti-prescription> ;
        fhir:v "http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/anti-prescription"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
      fhir:value [ a fhir:Boolean ; fhir:v true ]
    ]
  )
  …

The FHIR ontology includes a fhir:modifierExtensionClass property that relates each unmodified resource class to its corresponding modified resource class, so that SPARQL queries can easily find all modified classes without having to parse their URIs to look for the leading underscore:

fhir:MedicationRequest fhir:modifierExtensionClass fhir:_MedicationRequest .

BackboneElements and BackboneTypes are object types. Any RDF property that references a modified BackboneElement or BackboneType is prefixed with a '_'. Note the underscore at the beginning of "_value" in the following example:

<http://example.org/fhir/Observation/Obs123> a fhir:Observation;
  …
  fhir:_value [
    a fhir:Quantity;
    fhir:value [ fhir:v "185"^^xsd:decimal ];
    fhir:unit [ fhir:v "lbs" ];
    fhir:system [
      fhir:l <http://unitsofmeasure.org> ;
      fhir:v "http://unitsofmeasure.org"^^xsd:anyURI
    ];
    fhir:code [ fhir:v "[lb_av]" ];
    fhir:modifierExtension (
      [
        fhir:url [
          fhir:l <http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/anti-observation> ;
          fhir:v "http://example.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/anti-observation"^^xsd:anyURI ] ;
        fhir:value [ a fhir:Boolean ; fhir:v true ]
      ]
    ) ;
  ]

The FHIR ontology also includes a fhir:modifierExtensionProperty property that relates each unmodified property to its corresponding modified property:

fhir:value fhir:modifierExtensionProperty fhir:_value .

See Modifier Extensions for additional requirements around modifier extensions.

To facilitate FHIR RDF creation and processing, the following additional artifacts are available from the downloads page. While the fhir.hl7.org site icon holds the official released versions of these artifacts, unreleased INFORMATIVE versions may also be available from the build.fhir.org site icon.

  • ShEx schema fhir.shex (NORMATIVE). This schema is intended to help users validate FHIR RDF data. It is normative in the sense that if some purported FHIR RDF data is inconsistent with the ShEx schema, then that data is known to be invalid. However, consistency with the ShEx schema does not guarantee that the data is fully valid, because there are additional semantic requirements of FHIR data that are not captured in the ShEx schema.

    Although the logical meaning of the ShEx schema is normative, the expression of that meaning is INFORMATIVE (i.e., not normative): it MAY be changed or enhanced at any time. For example, the schema MAY be refactored, or shape names that only appear in the ShEx MAY change.

  • OWL Ontology fhir.ttl (NORMATIVE). This describes the classes and properties that are used to represent FHIR RDF data. It is normative in the sense that if an OWL reasoner finds some purported FHIR RDF data to be logically inconsistent with the ontology, then that data is known to be invalid, i.e., not conforming to the FHIR specification. However, consistency with the ontology does not guarantee that the data is fully valid, because there are many requirements of FHIR data that are not captured in the ontology.

    Although the logical meaning of the OWL ontology is normative, its expression in OWL/Turtle is INFORMATIVE (i.e., not normative): it MAY be changed or enhanced at any time. For example, it MAY be refactored, or class or property names that only appear in the ontology MAY change.

  • W5 Ontology w5.ttl (INFORMATIVE). This ontology attempts to capture relationships expressed in the Five Ws Mappings (formerly called W5 Report) -- Who, What, When, Where, Why. It has not been well vetted, and MAY be changed at any time.

  • v3 RIM ontology rim.ttl (INFORMATIVE). This ontology attempts to capture semantic relationships between HL7 v3 RIM icon and FHIR. It has not been well vetted, and may be changed at any time.

Informative

Application developers wishing to use FHIR RDF will often need to perform the following rough steps, though exact steps will depend on your application:

  1. Convert FHIR XML or FHIR JSON data to/from FHIR RDF. Open source implementations that can perform this conversion include: Check the HL7 Open Source FHIR Implementations page icon, in case new implementations have become available.
  2. Download the FHIR ontology, fhir.ttl .
  3. Download other ontologies that you wish to use with your application, such as the SNOMED-CT ontology. (Because of license restrictions, the process of obtaining the SNOMED-CT ontology is more complex than a simple download. Some guidance is provided here icon.)
  4. Create or obtain a bridge ontology that relates terms in the FHIR ontology to terms in your other ontologies.
  5. Load your FHIR RDF instance data and your ontologies into a reasoner and/or a triplestore, and perform SPARQL queries and/or reasoning.
  6. If you are creating FHIR RDF then you might also wish to validate it, using ShEx icon. You can download the ShEx schema for FHIR RDF.

OWL Caveat: RDF lists use a ladder of rdf:first and rdf:rest properties. This can cause problems in OWL DL, which disallows axioms over the rdf: namespace. To work around this problem, OWL users can convert RDF lists in their FHIR data to a different list representation. A script icon is available for doing such a conversion.

Informative

This page documents an RDF format that can be used to exchange FHIR data, on the basis that RDF is a universal information representation. Using RDF enables FHIR data to be used with other RDF data and RDF-aware applications to support inference, shared semantics across multiple standards and data formats, data integration, semantic data validation, compliance enforcement, SPARQL queries and other uses. Implementers using FHIR in this fashion are advised to be aware of the relationship between FHIR's RDF format and other uses of ontologies.

FHIR's RDF format is based on the same abstract information model as the XML and JSON formats and carries the same information content. Resources are losslessly round-trippable between XML, JSON and RDF formats and data expressed in the RDF format corresponds closely to the XML and JSON formats in its look and feel, though a few additional FHIR-specific terms appear in the RDF format, as explained above: fhir:nodeRole, fhir:treeRoot and fhir:v.

In addition to defining the RDF format, this specification provides an associated ontology containing formal definitions of the classes and properties that appear in the RDF format. Ontologies that were designed independently almost always have some impedance mismatch when attempting to use them together. Many of the ontologies in the medical and life sciences domain are designed to capture facts about the world for research, such as the fact that the mitral valve is a kind of heart valve. But FHIR was designed to support the day-to-day operations of healthcare providers exchanging electronic health records (EHRs), and in this context, the orientation has historically been different. When using FHIR RDF with other ontologies, impedance differences are likely to show up in two main ways:

  • Records versus facts. FHIR is oriented toward recording who did what ("Dr. Jones diagnosed patient x with viral pneumonia") rather than stating absolute medical facts ("patient x has viral pneumonia").
  • Non-monotonicity. RDF was designed to be monotonic, whereas FHIR has a few design aspects that would be non-monotonic if they were interpreted directly in RDF. (Monotonicity means that new data cannot invalidate previous conclusions; non-monotonicity means that previous conclusions can be invalidated by new data.) For example, a modifier extension indicates that the surrounding element's meaning will likely be misunderstood if the modifier extension is not understood.

For both of these reasons, to maintain monotonicity in RDF, users are advised to avoid directly interpreting FHIR RDF as stating facts. Transformations may be needed to remove or isolate non-monotonic elements and reconcile the records across time and perspective.

Application developers are also advised to be aware that some FHIR data attributes have a major impact on the interpretation of the enclosing data element: the meaning of the enclosing element cannot be determined in isolation. For example, a status of 'entered-in-error' means that the resource was created accidentally and is not clinically relevant.

Informative

Slides by Eric Prud'hommeaux icon illustrate how inference can be used on FHIR RDF data to perform a query for FHIR Observations of rheumatoid arthritis, using the SNOMED-CT ontology icon. Caveat: These slides were based on an earlier version of FHIR, so some specifics may have changed.

A webinar by Harold Solbrig icon shows how FHIR RDF data can be used with the SNOMED-CT ontology icon to recognize a cancer diagnosis.  An associated tutorial icon details the steps used.  Caveat: This webinar and tutorial were based on a previous version of FHIR RDF, so some specifics may have changed.

For background on concept IRIs, IRI stems, and their relationship to Code Systems, see Concept IRIs and IRI Stems above.

This section defines a standard algorithm for generating a Concept IRI from a <Coding.system, Coding.code> pair.  In many cases it involves merely concatenating the associated IRI Stem with the Coding.code.  But because a Coding.code could contain reserved characters that are used to delineate different parts of the IRI, percent-encoding of reserved characters is required, as defined below.

Given:

  • a FHIR Coding.system, s, that identifies a terminology t; and
  • a Coding.code, c, that is defined within t;

a Concept IRI, conceptIRI, corresponding to s and c is computed as follows:

  1. If no IRI Stem is defined for s in the HL7 Terminology website icon, then conceptIRI is undefined. Halt.
  2. Let iStem be an IRI Stem that is defined for s in the HL7 Terminology website. 
  3. As a special case, if iStem equals urn:ietf:rfc:3987, then conceptIRI is c, and c MUST be a syntactically valid absolute-IRI as defined by RFC 3987 icon.  Halt.  (Informative comments: The purpose of this special case is to permit System.codes that are already IRIs to be used directly as Concept IRIs, without any transformation. Note that an absolute-IRI may also be a URL or a URN.)
  4. Let cSafe be the IRI-safe version of c, as defined by the algorithm in section 7.3 of R2RML: RDB to RDF Mapping Language (W3C Recommendation 27 September 2012) icon, quoted here for convenience (informative):
    The IRI-safe version of a string is obtained by applying the following transformation to any character that is not in the iunreserved production icon in [RFC3987]:
    1. Convert the character to a sequence of one or more octets using UTF-8 [RFC3629]
    2. Percent-encode icon each octet [RFC3986]
    The iunreserved production defined in RFC 3987, section 2.2 icon using ABNF icon is also quoted here for convenience (informative):
    iunreserved    = ALPHA / DIGIT / "-" / "." / "_" / "~" / ucschar
    The ucschar production defined in RFC 3987, section 2.2 icon is also quoted here for convenience (informative).  (Informative comment: The ucschar production defines international character ranges that are valid Unicode characters within the intersection of path components (ipath), query strings (iquery) and fragment identifiers (ifragment).  They do not include any reserved characters involved in parsing apart the various components of an IRI.)
    ucschar        = %xA0-D7FF / %xF900-FDCF / %xFDF0-FFEF
                      / %x10000-1FFFD / %x20000-2FFFD / %x30000-3FFFD
                      / %x40000-4FFFD / %x50000-5FFFD / %x60000-6FFFD
                      / %x70000-7FFFD / %x80000-8FFFD / %x90000-9FFFD
                      / %xA0000-AFFFD / %xB0000-BFFFD / %xC0000-CFFFD
                      / %xD0000-DFFFD / %xE1000-EFFFD
  5. conceptIRI is the result of concatenating iStem and cSafe. Halt.

Some real and hypothetical examples are shown in the following table.

Coding.system

IRI Stem

Coding.code

Concept IRI

ICD 10:
http://hl7.org/fhir/sid/icd-10

http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/ICD10/

G44.1

http://purl.bioontology.org/ontology/ICD10/G44.1 

SNOMED CT:*
http://snomed.info/sct

http://snomed.info/id/

128045006

http://snomed.info/id/128045006

MeSH: https://www.nlm.nih.gov/mesh

https://id.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/

D000305

https://id.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/D000305

LOINC: http://loinc.org

https://loinc.org/rdf/

35217-9

https://loinc.org/rdf/35217-9

Example coding system that uses a Unicode smiling face character (U+263A) as a code:
http://example.org/

http://example.org/

http://example.org/

Example coding system that uses a Unicode waving hand character (U+1F44B) from the Miscellaneous Symbols and Pictographs icon block icon, combined with the medium-dark skin tone (U+1F3FE):
http://example.org/

http://example.org/

👋🏾

http://example.org/👋🏾 

*As of this writing (5-Sep-2022) it is not clear what IRI stem is most appropriate when writing a SNOMED CT post-coordinated code expression.

This section is intended for those who are helping to add or maintain IRI stem registrations at the HL7 Terminology website icon.

IRI stems have not been standardized for all FHIR Coding.systems. But any that have been standardized SHOULD be registered in the HL7 terminology website by adding appropriate CodeSystem and NamingSystem entries, using the system "urn:ietf:rfc:3987" and identifier type of "iri-stem". You can see an example of this in the HL7 description of the LOINC CodeSystem icon and the LOINC NamingSystem icon. Assuming that the Coding.system for your desired IRI stem has already been registered, the process for registering an IRI stem for it includes:

  1. Select the most authoritative, community-supported IRI stem available for this Coding.system. The IRI stem SHOULD be taken from an official publication of the organization that publishes the terminology (such as the LOINC User Guide mentioned above). If no such IRI stem is defined by the organization, and the organization fails to define or endorse one even after repeated requests, and the organization appears unlikely to define one in the foreseeable future, then a community-defined IRI stem MAY be registered. In this case, it SHOULD be an IRI stem most commonly used by the community as recorded by several RDF IRI stem repositories, such as Bioregistry icon, prefix.cc icon, OBO Foundry icon or Wikidata (by means of wdt:P1921 icon).
  2. The IRI stem MUST be in the form of an IRI as defined by the IRI production in RFC 3987 icon. This means that the IRI stem MUST start with a "scheme:" string, such as "http:", "https:", "urn:" or any other valid scheme, followed by an authority, followed by any number of path parts and an OPTIONAL query and fragment. Examples of valid IRI stems include:
    • doi:10.1111/
    • urn:loinc.org:     ← Note the trailing colon (":")
    • http://loinc.org/rdf/
    • http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/HP_     ← Note the trailing underscore ("_")
    • https://example.org/terminologies/?action=search&id=
    • ftp://user@example.org:2222/loinc/
  3. The IRI stem MUST be intended to be used by concatenating it with a FHIR code as described in the Appendix 1: Algorithm for creating a Concept IRI". Therefore, care must be taken to ensure that the code can be concatenated to the IRI stem without altering the IRI stem's meaning, including:
    1. The IRI stem SHOULD end with a delimiter character (one of the gen-delims or sub-delims productions from section 2.2 of RFC 3987 icon or one of the characters "-", ".", "_" or "~") . An IRI stem that ends with an alphanumeric character is likely to have the meaning of the final term altered when the code is concatenated. For example, an IRI stem of "http://example.org" when concatenated with the code "39" will result in a concept IRI of "http://example.org39", which is probably not the concept IRI intended.
    2. Since FHIR codes are percent-encoded before being concatenated with the IRI stem, it is unlikely that it will alter the meaning of the IRI stem. However, note that the characters `-`, `.`, `_`, `~` will NOT be percent encoded. Thus, if the IRI stem is `http://hospital.org`, a code of `.attacker.com` could be used to generate a concept IRI of `http://hospital.org.attacker.com`, which if resolved as a URL could provide information to an unexpected server name.
  4. On the HL7 Terminology website (https://terminology.hl7.org icon), add the IRI stem to the NamingSystem and CodeSystem records corresponding to the desired Coding.system, by following the process for submitting a UTG change proposal icon. The IRI stem SHOULD be added to both the NamingSystem and the CodeSystem. Additions, deletions and modifications of an IRI stem to an existing NamingSystem or CodeSystem will generally be considered a minor change under the UTG Versioning policy icon.

    As of this writing (17-Dec-2022), the change proposal process for doing this included the following steps. However, since the process may have later changed, readers are advised to verify it icon prior to proceeding. You can also see an example of such a change proposal, including the associated changes in the XML files, in the MeSH IRI stem change proposal icon.

    1. Record the IRI stem in a CodeSystem by adding an identifier with:
      • system: urn:ietf:rfc:3987
      • type: Coding with system=http://terminology.hl7.org/CodeSystem/v2-0203 and code="IRISTEM"
      • value: [the IRI stem]
      • period: [OPTIONAL: the period during which this IRI stem was in use]
      • assigner:
        • display: [documentation of the provenance of the IRI stem]
    2. Record the IRI stem in a NamingSystem by adding a uniqueId with:
      • type: iri-stem
      • value: [the IRI stem]
      • period: [OPTIONAL: the period during which this IRI stem was in use]
      • comment: [documentation of the provenance of the IRI stem]
      • preferred: false [since an IRI stem is unlikely to also be the primary identifier]
      • authoritative: [true if this IRI stem is officially recognized by the NamingSystem authority, false if this IRI stem is generally used in the RDF community but is not officially designated as such]
  5. If the current process for registering an IRI stem differs from the above steps, please:
    1. Search the Jira issue tracker icon for an issue titled "Registering an IRI Stem (RDF Subgroup)".
    2. If no such issue is found, file an issue icon with that title, describing how to improve the above steps.