Canonical Resource Management Infrastructure Implementation Guide
1.0.0-snapshot - Snapshot International flag

Canonical Resource Management Infrastructure Implementation Guide, published by HL7 International / Clinical Decision Support. This guide is not an authorized publication; it is the continuous build for version 1.0.0-snapshot built by the FHIR (HL7® FHIR® Standard) CI Build. This version is based on the current content of https://github.com/HL7/crmi-ig/ and changes regularly. See the Directory of published versions

Distribution

Distribution involves the APIs for searching and retrieving published artifacts. There are a few APIs this IG supports, including:

FHIR Packages / NPM

Like publishing, FHIR Packages are a way to distribute content. This is compatible with IG Publisher, SUSHI and the NPM client.

npm --registry=http://fhir-package-registry install @scope/fhir.uv.test.my-package

This example illustrates the use of an NPM package registry to install IG packages as NPM packages. This example also illustrates the use of NPM Scopes for FHIR packages.

FHIR REST API

Read and search operations can be used to distribute artifacts, see Artifact Repository and Artifact Terminology Service capability statements. FHIR read and search SHOULD be available for all canonical resources.

$package and $data-requirements

Downstream systems MAY require all content dependencies. These dependencies can cross IG/package boundaries, as intended for reusability (e.g. a common Library could be used by two Measures, or an ActivityDefinition could be used by several PlanDefinitions in different content IGs). Furthermore, some content might have been published outside a content IG/FHIR Package.

CRMI-PackageOperation.png

To facilitate this, a downstream system MAY use the $package or $data-requirements operation(s) on a canonical resource to resolve dependencies.

  • $package: The Artifact Repository assembles a FHIR Bundle of the target resource, and all of its dependencies for a client.
  • $data-requirements: The Artifact Repository assembles a FHIR Library with all the dependencies listed. The client can then download as needed.

NOTE: $data-requirements allows the client to decide what is needed to download (versus what might already have been downloaded), whereas $package always ships the actual resources.

Both $package and $data-requirements operations are available for all canonical resources:

  1. StructureDefinition, StructureMap
  2. ValueSet, CodeSystem, NamingSystem, ConceptMap
  3. Questionnaire, ActivityDefinition, PlanDefinition, Library, Measure
  4. ObservationDefinition, SpecimenDefinition, MedicationKnowledge, etc…

NOTE: To recreate the contents of a FHIR Package, the $package operation could be called on the ImplementationGuide resource with appropriate parameters to only include local resources defined in the package (i.e. packageOnly set to true).

Dependency Tracing

Dependency tracing is the process of determining, given a root artifact, what other artifacts are referenced by the artifact, recursively, to produce a complete listing of all the artifacts (or dependencies) required for the artifact to be used. Because FHIR artifacts in general have many different ways of referencing other artifacts, the process needs to be described per resource type. In addition, because new extensions can be introduced and used at any point, the process needs to support a mechanism for allowing new content to indicate whether it constitutes a dependency for this purpose.

In general, the process considers each element of a resource and, if it is a canonical reference, or a reference to an “artifact” resource as described by this implementation guide, it is traced. In addition, extensions used in quality improvement profiles such as Clinical Guidelines and Quality Measures, are considered.

The following sections describe the dependency references for each type of resource. Note that this dependency-listing is not exhaustive, but captures the required dependencies for the quality improvement use case. The cqf-shouldTraceDependency extension can be used in the definition of an extension or profile to indicate whether the element should be traced as a dependency for the purposes of packaging and distribution.

Each section provides a listing of the paths to each element that should be considered as a reference to an artifact (and recursively traced for dependencies as well) using a FHIRPath-like syntax, with abbreviated references to the names of extensions to be followed.

Note that the following extensions may be safely ignored for the purposes of dependency tracing:

StructureDefinition http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/elementdefinition-type-must-support
StructureDefinition http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/elementdefinition-type-must-support
StructureDefinition http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/codesystem-properties-mode

Resource

meta.profile

Structure Definition

For structure definitions, only the differential element is considered, on the basis that the baseDefinition will be traced, so anything in the snapshots will be covered by tracing up the hierarchy.

extension[].url
modifierExtension[].url
baseDefinition
differential.element[].type.code
differential.element[].type.profile[]
differential.element[].type.targetProfile[]
differential.element[].binding.valueSet
differential.element[].extension[].url
differential.element[].modifierExtension[].url
extension[cpg-inferenceExpression].reference
extension[cpg-assertionExpression].reference
extension[cpg-featureExpression].reference

Structure Map

structure[].url
import[]
group[].rule[]..source[].defaultValue[x]

ValueSet

compose.include[].valueSet
compose.include[].system
compose.exclude[].valueSet
compose.exclude[].system

CodeSystem

valueSet // NOTE: This element may be skipped because if the value set is really used by artifacts it will be referenced
supplements

NamingSystem

(none)

ConceptMap

sourceCanonical
targetCanonical
group.source
group.target
group[].element[].target[].dependsOn[].system
group[].element[].target[].product[]..system
unmapped.url

Questionnaire

derivedFrom
item[]..definition // NOTE: This is not a simple canonical, it will have a fragment to identify the specific element
item[]..answerValueSet
item[]..extension[itemMedia]
item[]..extension[itemAnswerMedia]
item[]..extension[unitValueSet]
item[]..extension[referenceProfile]
item[]..extension[candidateExpression].reference
item[]..extension[lookupQuestionnaire]
extension[cqf-library]
extension[launchContext]
extension[variable].reference
item[]..extension[variable].reference
item[]..extension[initialExpression].reference
item[]..extension[calculatedExpression].reference
item[]..extension[cqf-calculatedValue].reference
item[]..extension[cqf-expression].reference
item[]..extension[sdc-questionnaire-subQuestionnaire]

ActivityDefinition

relatedArtifact[].resource
library[]
profile
location
productReference
specimenRequirement[]
observationRequirement[]
observationResultRequirement[]
transform
extension[cpg-collectWith]
extension[cpg-enrollIn]
extension[cpg-reportWith]

PlanDefinition

relatedArtifact[].resource
library[]
action[]..trigger[].dataRequirement[].profile[]
action[]..trigger[].dataRequirement[].codeFilter[].valueSet
action[]..condition[].expression.reference
action[]..input[].profile[]
action[]..input[].codeFilter[].valueSet
action[]..output[].profile[]
action[]..output[].codeFilter[].valueSet
action[]..definitionCanonical
action[]..dynamicValue[].expression.reference
extension[cpg-partOf]

Library

relatedArtifact[].resource
dataRequirement[].profile[]
dataRequirement[].codeFilter[].valueSet

Measure

relatedArtifact[].resource
library[]
group[].population[].criteria.reference
group[].stratifier[].criteria.reference
group[].stratifier[].component[].criteria.reference
supplementalData[].criteria.reference
extension[cqfm-inputParameters][]
extension[cqfm-expansionParameters][]
extension[cqfm-effectiveDataRequirements]
extension[cqfm-cqlOptions]
extension[cqfm-component][].resource

GraphDefinition

extension[cpg-relatedArtifact].reference

ImplementationGuide

extension[cpg-relatedArtifact].reference

Ingredient

for

Medication

manufacturer
ingredient[].itemReference

Substance

ingredient[].substanceReference

Parameters

parameter[].resource

MedicationKnowledge

relatedMedicationKnowledge[].reference
monograph[].source
ingredient[].itemReference
regulatory[].regulatoryAuthority

Manifest

Canonical references MAY be authored without a version. To ensure consistent versions of resources are used by downstream systems, a manifest parameter to specify canonical versions MAY be passed to FHIR operations that use dynamic requirements: $package and $data-requirements; in addition to execution operations that can use a content endpoint to resolve canonical resources such as $apply from CPG and $evaluate-measure from DEQM IG.

More information on manifest specification

Syndication

Syndication allows broadcasting of content changes to interested parties. The syndication mechanism proposed in the IG MAY be used by downstream systems, or federated Artifact Repositories so preemptive downloading, or notification message send to interested parties.

The syndication API SHALL be based on ATOM, an example is shown below:

<!-- see: https://validator.w3.org/feed/docs/atom.html -->
<feed xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:hl7="http://hl7.org/fhir/uv/crmi/syndication">
  <title>HL7 CRMI Knowledge Artifact Server Feed</title>
  <link rel="self" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://crmi-server/syndication/v1/feed.xml" />
  <id>urn:uuid:e39958d4-380e-4252-8707-6afeff8b7911</id>
  <updated>2023-01-01T01:00:00Z</updated>
  <entry>
    <id>urn:uuid:2c466218-337c-3367-95d9-57f65cd1a572</id>
    <title>SomeMeasure Package</title>
    <updated>2020-08-23T23:37:17Z</updated>
    <published>2020-08-23T23:37:17Z</published>
    <hl7:artifactVersion>0.0.0</hl7:artifactVersion>
    <hl7:artifactType>package</hl7:artifactType>
    <hl7:fhirVersion>4.0.1</hl7:fhirVersion>
    <hl7:publishAction>publish</hl7:publishAction>
    <author>
      <name>SomeMeasure Agency</name>
      <uri>http://www.measure.org</uri>
      <email>help@measure.org</email>
    </author>
    <!-- when publishing a new FHIR package, we expose both the package tarball -->
    <link rel="alternate" type="application/fhir+gzip"
      href="https://crmi-server/packages/some.fhir.uv.somemeasure/-/some.fhir.uv.somemeasure-0.0.0.tgz" />
    <!-- also include a Bundle transaction of all resources in the direct package with conditional create url and version -->
    <link rel="alternate" type="application/fhir+json"
      href="https://crmi-server/Bundle/f0099e15-3c06-4905-ba65-86749757fe80" />
    <summary>Contains updates to SomeMeasure, a quality measure you need in your life.</summary>
    <rights>Copyright 2019 SomeMeasure Agency. This content contains information which is protected
      by copyright. All Rights Reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced or used in any form
      or by any means - graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including photocopying, recording,
      taping, or information storage and retrieval systems - without the permission of the
      SomeMeasure Agency.</rights>
  </entry>
  <entry>
    <id>urn:uuid:16d8afdf-79d4-4dfe-87ce-cfc6cd186f62</id>
    <title>ValueSet ABC Removed</title>
    <updated>2020-08-23T23:37:17Z</updated>
    <hl7:fhirVersion>4.0.1</hl7:fhirVersion>
    <hl7:artifactType>resource</hl7:artifactType>
    <hl7:publishAction>unpublish</hl7:publishAction>
    <!-- this is a transaction bundle with a conditional delete using the canonical url and version -->
    <link rel="alternate" type="application/fhir+json; fhirVersion=4.0"
      href="https://crmi-server/Bundle/b8e21acc-a8ee-41d5-acac-b7331d675fbe"/>
  </entry>
  <entry>
    <id>urn:uuid:c4ae3f0f-2aaf-4afc-9752-e5d856b45461</id>
    <title>Update FHIR Library</title>
    <updated>2020-08-23T23:37:17Z</updated>
    <hl7:artifactVersion>0.2.1</hl7:artifactVersion>
    <hl7:artifactType>resource</hl7:artifactType>
    <hl7:fhirVersion>4.0.1</hl7:fhirVersion>
    <hl7:publishAction>publish</hl7:publishAction>
    <!-- this is a transaction bundle with a conditional create using the canonical url and version -->
    <link rel="alternate" type="application/fhir+json; fhirVersion=4.0"
      href="https://crmi-server/Bundle/d654dcde-ba89-4f6e-9024-bced216d58e9"/>
  </entry>
</feed>

Uplinks or mirrors are common in software artifact registries. Many times organizations have a virtualized registry that can route installation requests either locally (for local, private packages) or remotely to configured uplinks as show below:

CRMI-Uplinks.png

This can simplify tooling for distribution to downstream systems, and can decrease brittleness relying on upstream systems to be available.

Downstream System(s)

Systems using sharable content, including: authoring systems, clinical data repositories, quality measure engines, decision support engines, care management systems, and assessment filler applications.

Distribution client capabilities

Distribution clients must be able to consume the artifacts produced by upstream systems, either as IG packages, or as artifact bundles, depending on how the upstream systems choose to distribute artifact content.

For IG packages, the FHIR publishing ecosystem, including the FHIR validation tooling, already provide implementation support for integrating with the FHIR registry to download packaged implementation guide content as published for FHIR implementation guides. Applications can either make use of this existing tooling, or build tooling appropriate for their platform to integrate with the FHIR registry feed (or other upstream feeds as described above).

Note that for artifact bundles that are the result of the $package operation, bundles may be requested that include duplicate artifacts. Client applications that consume artifact bundles must be prepared for this case.

In addition, client applications must ensure that artifact references are resolved correctly. If an artifact reference is unversioned, a version manifest for the artifact should be consulted to determine the appropriate version-binding information. See the Artifact Scope discussion for information on how to identify the version manifest appropriate for a particular artifact.