AI Transparency on FHIR, published by HL7 International / Electronic Health Records. This guide is not an authorized publication; it is the continuous build for version 1.0.0 built by the FHIR (HL7® FHIR® Standard) CI Build. This version is based on the current content of https://github.com/HL7/aitransparency-ig/ and changes regularly. See the Directory of published versions
| Page standards status: Informative |
This page tracks the signficant changes. All changes are tracked in Jira and on GitHub.
Since the ballot publication, this version refines the scope and terminology and clarifies how AI involvement is identified and recorded in FHIR resources. It strengthens guidance for resource labeling and Provenance, updates the representation of AI systems and their model cards and prompts, adds a way to convey inference confidence, and expands implementation guidance and future considerations.
Non-Compatible
| Ticket | Ticket Description |
|---|---|
| FHIR-57918 | Remove experimental provenance codes |
| FHIR-54801 | Remove code AIRPT |
| FHIR-54368 | Revise codes in AIdeviceTypeVS - different AI technologies and fleshes out a bit the scenarios and data types. |
| FHIR-54267 | Require DocumentReference, and put futures on independent informative page. |
| FHIR-54527 | Remove use of Device.note to reduce variability on R4 AI device modeling |
Compatible, Substantive
| Ticket | Ticket Description |
|---|---|
| FHIR-54280 | AIAST meta labeling is required always. |
| FHIR-54141 | Remove experimental codes |
| FHIR-54244 | Include an extension to capture the certainty of an AI inference |
| FHIR-54734 | For better readability, switch section 2 and 3 |
| FHIR-54279 | Explain how to discover that AI was used, and how to find the provenance or label that indicates this. |
| FHIR-54726 | Scope needs some refinement |
| FHIR-54723 | AI device conflicting type binding and property fixed values and extension |
| FHIR-54707 | Refrain from using Tag, use Label |
| FHIR-54280 | address if labeling is mandatory or optional – make the resource level labeling mandatory |
Non-Substantive
| Ticket | Ticket Description |
|---|---|
| FHIR-54580 | AIAST meta labeling is required always. |
| FHIR-54894 | refine use of "observability" and "transparency" in the document (previously applied) |
| FHIR-55024 | Description of algorithm deterministic/nonderministic/hybird (previously applied) |
| FHIR-57756 | More narrative explanation of element level Provenance explaining the extensions |
| FHIR-54180 | Describe plans for R5/R6 |
| FHIR-53975 | Order of Relationship between Device and Model-Card |
| FHIR-54371 | AI Device representation and its elements |
| FHIR-54391 | Provide a position on the preferred model card - indifferent |
| FHIR-54528 | Describe how to exchange AI provenance via RESTful create |
| FHIR-54281 | Explain how to discover that AI was used, and how to find the provenance or label that indicates this. |
| FHIR-54885 | Add some clarifying text to the Scope section that detection is not in scope |
| FHIR-54893 | Clarify AI vs non-AI scope to avoid inconsistent observability implementations. |
| FHIR-54233 | Elaborate the Operation section |
| FHIR-53973 | Clarification on input data |
| FHIR-54725 | Remove unusable AI-Data Profile on Resource as not usable. |
| FHIR-54894 | refine use of "observability" and "transparency" in the document |
| FHIR-55024 | Description of algorithm deterministic/nonderministic/hybird |
| FHIR-54757 | clarify combining AIdevice profile with other device profiles such as a smart watch. |
| FHIR-54583 | clarify use of AI Transparency in post market surveillance |
Initial Public-Comment
Non-Compatible
none
Compatible, Substantive
| Ticket | Ticket Description |
|---|---|
| FHIR-54421 | Add a profile of DocumentReference for AI Input Prompts as distinct from Model-Cards |
| FHIR-54264 | Add a profile of DocumentReference for AI Input Prompts as distinct from Model-Cards |
| FHIR-54577 | Add a profile of DocumentReference for AI Input Prompts as distinct from Model-Cards |
Non-Substantive
| Ticket | Ticket Description |
|---|---|
| FHIR-54259 | Add a profile of DocumentReference for AI Input Prompts as distinct from Model-Cards |
| FHIR-54149 | AIinputsCS - CodeSystem title inconsistent with computable name |