Profile Comparison between http://hl7.org/fhir/us/core/StructureDefinition/us-core-organization vs http://hl7.org/fhir/us/pq-cmc-fda/StructureDefinition/mfg-test-site-organization

Left:US Core Organization Profile (http://hl7.org/fhir/us/core/StructureDefinition/us-core-organization)
Right:Manufacturing and/or Test Site Organization (http://hl7.org/fhir/us/pq-cmc-fda/StructureDefinition/mfg-test-site-organization)

Messages

ErrorStructureDefinition.urlValues for url differ: 'http://hl7.org/fhir/us/core/StructureDefinition/us-core-organization' vs 'http://hl7.org/fhir/us/pq-cmc-fda/StructureDefinition/mfg-test-site-organization'
ErrorStructureDefinition.versionValues for version differ: '7.0.0-ballot' vs '0.1.20'
InformationStructureDefinition.nameValues for name differ: 'USCoreOrganizationProfile' vs 'MfgTestSiteOrganization'
InformationStructureDefinition.titleValues for title differ: 'US Core Organization Profile' vs 'Manufacturing and/or Test Site Organization'
InformationStructureDefinition.statusValues for status differ: 'active' vs 'draft'
InformationStructureDefinition.dateValues for date differ: '2022-04-20' vs '2024-03-04T02:24:01+00:00'
InformationStructureDefinition.publisherValues for publisher differ: 'HL7 International / Cross-Group Projects' vs 'HL7 International / Biomedical Research and Regulation'
WarningStructureDefinition.fhirVersionValues for fhirVersion differ: '4.0.1' vs '5.0.0'
WarningStructureDefinition.abstractValues for abstract differ: 'false' vs 'true'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: '\-' vs 'A formally or informally recognized grouping of people or organizations formed for the purpose of achieving some form of collective action. Includes companies, institutions, corporations, departments, community groups, healthcare practice groups, payer/insurer, etc.'
InformationStructureDefinition.commentValues for comment differ: 'The only time that a resource does not have an id is when it is being submitted to the server using a create operation.' vs 'Within the context of the FHIR RESTful interactions, the resource has an id except for cases like the create and conditional update. Otherwise, the use of the resouce id depends on the given use case.'
InformationStructureDefinition.commentValues for comment differ: 'Asserting this rule set restricts the content to be only understood by a limited set of trading partners. This inherently limits the usefulness of the data in the long term. However, the existing health eco-system is highly fractured, and not yet ready to define, collect, and exchange data in a generally computable sense. Wherever possible, implementers and/or specification writers should avoid using this element. Often, when used, the URL is a reference to an implementation guide that defines these special rules as part of it's narrative along with other profiles, value sets, etc.' vs 'Asserting this rule set restricts the content to be only understood by a limited set of trading partners. This inherently limits the usefulness of the data in the long term. However, the existing health eco-system is highly fractured, and not yet ready to define, collect, and exchange data in a generally computable sense. Wherever possible, implementers and/or specification writers should avoid using this element. Often, when used, the URL is a reference to an implementation guide that defines these special rules as part of its narrative along with other profiles, value sets, etc.'
InformationStructureDefinition.commentValues for comment differ: 'Contained resources do not have narrative. Resources that are not contained SHOULD have a narrative. In some cases, a resource may only have text with little or no additional discrete data (as long as all minOccurs=1 elements are satisfied). This may be necessary for data from legacy systems where information is captured as a 'text blob' or where text is additionally entered raw or narrated and encoded information is added later.' vs 'Contained resources do not have a narrative. Resources that are not contained SHOULD have a narrative. In some cases, a resource may only have text with little or no additional discrete data (as long as all minOccurs=1 elements are satisfied). This may be necessary for data from legacy systems where information is captured as a 'text blob' or where text is additionally entered raw or narrated and encoded information is added later.'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'These resources do not have an independent existence apart from the resource that contains them - they cannot be identified independently, and nor can they have their own independent transaction scope.' vs 'These resources do not have an independent existence apart from the resource that contains them - they cannot be identified independently, nor can they have their own independent transaction scope. This is allowed to be a Parameters resource if and only if it is referenced by a resource that provides context/meaning.'
InformationStructureDefinition.commentValues for comment differ: 'This should never be done when the content can be identified properly, as once identification is lost, it is extremely difficult (and context dependent) to restore it again. Contained resources may have profiles and tags In their meta elements, but SHALL NOT have security labels.' vs 'This should never be done when the content can be identified properly, as once identification is lost, it is extremely difficult (and context dependent) to restore it again. Contained resources may have profiles and tags in their meta elements, but SHALL NOT have security labels.'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the resource. To make the use of extensions safe and manageable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer can define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension.' vs 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the resource. To make the use of extensions safe and managable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer can define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension.'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the resource and that modifies the understanding of the element that contains it and/or the understanding of the containing element's descendants. Usually modifier elements provide negation or qualification. To make the use of extensions safe and manageable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer is allowed to define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension. Applications processing a resource are required to check for modifier extensions. Modifier extensions SHALL NOT change the meaning of any elements on Resource or DomainResource (including cannot change the meaning of modifierExtension itself).' vs 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the resource and that modifies the understanding of the element that contains it and/or the understanding of the containing element's descendants. Usually modifier elements provide negation or qualification. To make the use of extensions safe and managable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer is allowed to define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension. Applications processing a resource are required to check for modifier extensions. Modifier extensions SHALL NOT change the meaning of any elements on Resource or DomainResource (including cannot change the meaning of modifierExtension itself).'
InformationStructureDefinition.requirementsValues for requirements differ: 'Modifier extensions allow for extensions that *cannot* be safely ignored to be clearly distinguished from the vast majority of extensions which can be safely ignored. This promotes interoperability by eliminating the need for implementers to prohibit the presence of extensions. For further information, see the [definition of modifier extensions](http://hl7.org/fhir/R4/extensibility.html#modifierExtension).' vs 'Modifier extensions allow for extensions that *cannot* be safely ignored to be clearly distinguished from the vast majority of extensions which can be safely ignored. This promotes interoperability by eliminating the need for implementers to prohibit the presence of extensions. For further information, see the [definition of modifier extensions](http://hl7.org/fhir/R5/extensibility.html#modifierExtension).'
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'Identifies this organization across multiple systems' vs 'Manufacturing Site Unique Identifier | Testing Site Unique Identifier'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'Identifier for the organization that is used to identify the organization across multiple disparate systems.' vs 'Manufacturing Site Unique Identifier: A unique identifier assigned to the establishment (facility) which manufactures, prepares, propagates, compounds or processes drugs. [Source: Adapted from FDA Drug Establishment Current Registration Site] Testing Site Unique Identifier: A unique identifier assigned to the establishment (facility) which performs the testing. [Source: SME Defined]'
InformationOrganization.identifierElement minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the element. To make the use of extensions safe and manageable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer can define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension.' vs 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the element. To make the use of extensions safe and managable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer can define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension.'
ErrorOrganization.identifier.useUnable to resolve left value set http://hl7.org/fhir/ValueSet/identifier-use|4.0.1 at Organization.identifier.use
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'Description of identifier' vs 'Manufacturing Site Unique Identifier Type | Testing Site Unique Identifier Type'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'A coded type for the identifier that can be used to determine which identifier to use for a specific purpose.' vs 'A value that identifies the source of the unique identifier. [Source: SME Defined] Examples: Data Universal Number System (DUNS), Facility Establishment Identifiers (FEI), etc.'
WarningOrganization.identifier.typeElements differ in definition for mustSupport: 'false' vs 'true'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'Establishes the namespace for the value - that is, a URL that describes a set values that are unique.' vs 'Establishes the namespace for the value - that is, an absolute URL that describes a set values that are unique.'
InformationOrganization.identifier.systemElement minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
InformationStructureDefinition.commentValues for comment differ: 'If the value is a full URI, then the system SHALL be urn:ietf:rfc:3986. The value's primary purpose is computational mapping. As a result, it may be normalized for comparison purposes (e.g. removing non-significant whitespace, dashes, etc.) A value formatted for human display can be conveyed using the [Rendered Value extension](http://hl7.org/fhir/R4/extension-rendered-value.html). Identifier.value is to be treated as case sensitive unless knowledge of the Identifier.system allows the processer to be confident that non-case-sensitive processing is safe.' vs 'If the value is a full URI, then the system SHALL be urn:ietf:rfc:3986. The value's primary purpose is computational mapping. As a result, it may be normalized for comparison purposes (e.g. removing non-significant whitespace, dashes, etc.) A value formatted for human display can be conveyed using the [http://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/rendered-value](http://hl7.org/fhir/extensions/StructureDefinition-rendered-value.html)). Identifier.value is to be treated as case sensitive unless knowledge of the Identifier.system allows the processer to be confident that non-case-sensitive processing is safe.'
InformationOrganization.identifier.valueElement minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
WarningOrganization.activeElements differ in definition for mustSupport: 'true' vs 'false'
InformationOrganization.activeElement minimum cardinalities differ: '1' vs '0'
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'Name used for the organization' vs 'Manufacturing Site Name | Testing Site Name'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'A name associated with the organization.' vs 'Manufacturing Site Name: The name of the establishment (facilities) which manufacture, prepare, propagate, compound, process or package drugs that are commercially distributed in the U.S. or offered for import to the U.S[Source: Adapted from FDA Drug Establishment Current Registration Site] Testing Site Name: The name of the establishment (facility) which tests the raw materials, intermediates, drug substance, drug product, packaging components. [Source: SME Defined]'
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'Contact for the organization for a certain purpose' vs 'Official contact details for the Organization'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'Contact for the organization for a certain purpose.' vs 'The contact details of communication devices available relevant to the specific Organization. This can include addresses, phone numbers, fax numbers, mobile numbers, email addresses and web sites.'
InformationStructureDefinition.commentValues for comment differ: 'Where multiple contacts for the same purpose are provided there is a standard extension that can be used to determine which one is the preferred contact to use.' vs 'The address/telecom use code 'home' are not to be used. Note that these contacts are not the contact details of people who provide the service (that would be through PractitionerRole), these are official contacts for the Organization itself for specific purposes. E.g. Mailing Addresses, Billing Addresses, Contact numbers for Booking or Billing Enquiries, general web address, web address for online bookings etc.'
InformationOrganization.contactElement minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
InformationOrganization.contactElement maximum cardinalities differ: '2147483647' vs '1'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the element. To make the use of extensions safe and manageable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer can define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension.' vs 'May be used to represent additional information that is not part of the basic definition of the element. To make the use of extensions safe and managable, there is a strict set of governance applied to the definition and use of extensions. Though any implementer can define an extension, there is a set of requirements that SHALL be met as part of the definition of the extension.'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'Indicates a purpose for which the contact can be reached.' vs 'The purpose/type of contact.'
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'A name associated with the contact' vs 'Name of an individual to contact'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'A name associated with the contact.' vs 'The name of an individual to contact, some types of contact detail are usually blank.'
InformationOrganization.contact.nameElement maximum cardinalities differ: '1' vs '2147483647'
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'Contact details (telephone, email, etc.) for a contact' vs 'Contact details (e.g.phone/fax/url)'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'A contact detail (e.g. a telephone number or an email address) by which the party may be contacted.' vs 'The contact details application for the purpose defined.'
InformationStructureDefinition.shortValues for short differ: 'Visiting or postal addresses for the contact' vs 'Manufacturing Site Physical Address | Testing Site Address'
InformationStructureDefinition.definitionValues for definition differ: 'Visiting or postal addresses for the contact.' vs 'Manufacturing Site Physical Address: The complete address for the supplier [Source: SME Defined] Testing Site Address: The complete address for the testing site. [Source: SME defined]'
WarningOrganization.contact.addressElements differ in definition for mustSupport: 'false' vs 'true'
InformationOrganization.contact.addressElement minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'

Metadata

NameValueComments
.abstractfalsetrue
  • Values Differ
.baseDefinitionhttp://hl7.org/fhir/StructureDefinition/Organization
    .copyrightUsed by permission of HL7 International, all rights reserved Creative Commons License
    • Removed the item 'Used by permission of HL7 International, all rights reserved Creative Commons License'
    .date2022-04-202024-03-04T02:24:01+00:00
    • Values Differ
    .descriptionThis profile sets minimum expectations for the Organization resource to searching for and fetching an Organization associated with a patient or provider to promote interoperability and adoption through common implementation. It identifies which core elements, extensions, vocabularies, and value sets **SHALL** be present and constrains the way the elements are used and constrains the way the elements are used when using the profile. It provides the floor for standards development for specific use cases.A profile for the data elements required to identify an organization that manufactures, processes or tests drug products or substances.
    • Values Differ
    .experimentalfalse
    • Removed the item 'false'
    .fhirVersion4.0.15.0.0
    • Values Differ
    .jurisdiction
      ..jurisdiction[0]urn:iso:std:iso:3166#US
        .kindresource
          .nameUSCoreOrganizationProfileMfgTestSiteOrganization
          • Values Differ
          .publisherHL7 International / Cross-Group ProjectsHL7 International / Biomedical Research and Regulation
          • Values Differ
          .purpose
            .statusactivedraft
            • Values Differ
            .titleUS Core Organization ProfileManufacturing and/or Test Site Organization
            • Values Differ
            .typeOrganization
              .urlhttp://hl7.org/fhir/us/core/StructureDefinition/us-core-organizationhttp://hl7.org/fhir/us/pq-cmc-fda/StructureDefinition/mfg-test-site-organization
              • Values Differ
              .version7.0.0-ballot0.1.20
              • Values Differ

              Structure

              NameL FlagsL Card.L TypeL Description & ConstraintsR FlagsR Card.L TypeL Description & ConstraintsCommentsdoco
              .. Organization C0..*OrganizationA grouping of people or organizations with a common purpose
              org-1: The organization SHALL at least have a name or an identifier, and possibly more than one
              C0..*OrganizationThis is an abstract profile.
              A grouping of people or organizations with a common purpose
              org-1: The organization SHALL at least have a name or an identifier, and possibly more than one
                ... id Σ0..1idLogical id of this artifactΣ0..1idLogical id of this artifact
                  ... meta Σ0..1MetaMetadata about the resourceΣ0..1MetaMetadata about the resource
                    .... id 0..1idUnique id for inter-element referencing
                    • Added this element
                    .... Slices for extension 0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                    Slice: Unordered, Open by value:url
                    • Added this element
                    .... versionId Σ0..1idVersion specific identifier
                    • Added this element
                    .... lastUpdated Σ0..1instantWhen the resource version last changed
                    • Added this element
                    .... source Σ0..1uriIdentifies where the resource comes from
                    • Added this element
                    .... profile SΣ1..1canonical(StructureDefinition)Profiles this resource claims to conform to
                    • Added this element
                    .... security Σ0..*CodingSecurity Labels applied to this resource
                    Binding: ?? (extensible): Security Labels from the Healthcare Privacy and Security Classification System.


                    • Added this element
                    .... tag Σ0..*CodingTags applied to this resource
                    Binding: ?? (example): Codes that represent various types of tags, commonly workflow-related; e.g. "Needs review by Dr. Jones".


                    • Added this element
                    ... implicitRules ?!Σ0..1uriA set of rules under which this content was created?!Σ0..1uriA set of rules under which this content was created
                      ... text 0..1NarrativeText summary of the resource, for human interpretation0..1NarrativeText summary of the resource, for human interpretation
                        ... contained 0..*ResourceContained, inline Resources
                        0..*ResourceContained, inline Resources
                          ... extension 0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                          0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                            ... modifierExtension ?!0..*ExtensionExtensions that cannot be ignored
                            ?!Σ0..*ExtensionExtensions that cannot be ignored
                              ... Slices for identifier SΣC0..*IdentifierIdentifies this organization across multiple systems
                              Slice: Unordered, Open by pattern:$this
                              SΣC1..*IdentifierManufacturing Site Unique Identifier | Testing Site Unique Identifier
                              Slice: Unordered, Open by value:system
                              • Element minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
                              .... id 0..1stringUnique id for inter-element referencing0..1idUnique id for inter-element referencing
                                .... Slices for extension 0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                                Slice: Unordered, Open by value:url
                                0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                                Slice: Unordered, Open by value:url
                                  .... use ?!Σ0..1codeusual | official | temp | secondary | old (If known)
                                  Binding: ?? (required): Identifies the purpose for this identifier, if known .

                                  ?!Σ0..1codeusual | official | temp | secondary | old (If known)
                                  Binding: ?? (required): Identifies the purpose for this identifier, if known .

                                  • Unable to resolve left value set http://hl7.org/fhir/ValueSet/identifier-use|4.0.1 at Organization.identifier.use
                                  .... type Σ0..1CodeableConceptDescription of identifier
                                  Binding: ?? (extensible): A coded type for an identifier that can be used to determine which identifier to use for a specific purpose.

                                  SΣ0..1CodeableConceptManufacturing Site Unique Identifier Type | Testing Site Unique Identifier Type
                                  Binding: ?? (required)
                                  • Elements differ in definition for mustSupport: 'false' vs 'true'
                                  .... system SΣ0..1uriThe namespace for the identifier value
                                  Example General: http://www.acme.com/identifiers/patient
                                  SΣ1..1uriThe namespace for the identifier value
                                  Example General: http://www.acme.com/identifiers/patient
                                  • Element minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
                                  .... value SΣ0..1stringThe value that is unique
                                  Example General: 123456
                                  SΣC1..1stringThe value that is unique
                                  Example General: 123456
                                  • Element minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
                                  .... period Σ0..1PeriodTime period when id is/was valid for useΣ0..1PeriodTime period when id is/was valid for use
                                    .... assigner Σ0..1Reference(Organization)Organization that issued id (may be just text)Σ0..1Reference(Organization)Organization that issued id (may be just text)
                                      ... active ?!SΣ1..1booleanWhether the organization's record is still in active use?!Σ0..1booleanWhether the organization's record is still in active use
                                      • Elements differ in definition for mustSupport: 'true' vs 'false'
                                      • Element minimum cardinalities differ: '1' vs '0'
                                      ... type Σ0..*CodeableConceptKind of organization
                                      Binding: ?? (example): Used to categorize the organization.


                                      Σ0..*CodeableConceptKind of organization
                                      Binding: ?? (example): Used to categorize the organization.


                                        ... name SΣC1..1stringName used for the organizationSΣC1..1stringManufacturing Site Name | Testing Site Name
                                          ... alias 0..*stringA list of alternate names that the organization is known as, or was known as in the past
                                          0..*stringA list of alternate names that the organization is known as, or was known as in the past
                                            ... telecom SC0..*ContactPointA contact detail for the organization
                                            org-3: The telecom of an organization can never be of use 'home'
                                            • Removed this element
                                            ... address SC0..*AddressAn address for the organization
                                            org-2: An address of an organization can never be of use 'home'
                                            • Removed this element
                                            ... partOf Σ0..1Reference(Organization)The organization of which this organization forms a partΣ0..1Reference(Organization)The organization of which this organization forms a part
                                              ... contact 0..*BackboneElementContact for the organization for a certain purpose
                                              C1..1ExtendedContactDetailOfficial contact details for the Organization
                                              org-3: The telecom of an organization can never be of use 'home'
                                              org-4: The address of an organization can never be of use 'home'
                                              • Element minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
                                              • Element maximum cardinalities differ: '2147483647' vs '1'
                                              .... id 0..1stringUnique id for inter-element referencing0..1idUnique id for inter-element referencing
                                                .... extension 0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                                                0..*ExtensionAdditional content defined by implementations
                                                Slice: Unordered, Open by value:url
                                                  .... modifierExtension ?!Σ0..*ExtensionExtensions that cannot be ignored even if unrecognized
                                                  • Removed this element
                                                  .... purpose 0..1CodeableConceptThe type of contact
                                                  Binding: ?? (extensible): The purpose for which you would contact a contact party.

                                                  Σ0..1CodeableConceptThe type of contact
                                                  Binding: ?? (preferred): The purpose for which an extended contact detail should be used.

                                                    .... name 0..1HumanNameA name associated with the contactΣ0..*HumanNameName of an individual to contact
                                                    • Element maximum cardinalities differ: '1' vs '2147483647'
                                                    .... telecom 0..*ContactPointContact details (telephone, email, etc.) for a contact
                                                    Σ0..*ContactPointContact details (e.g.phone/fax/url)
                                                      .... address 0..1AddressVisiting or postal addresses for the contactSC1..1??Manufacturing Site Physical Address | Testing Site Address
                                                      addr-state: If the country is USA, then the state and postal code exist
                                                      addr-zip: If the country is USA, then the postal code is 5 digits with an optional dash and 4 numbers
                                                      • Elements differ in definition for mustSupport: 'false' vs 'true'
                                                      • Element minimum cardinalities differ: '0' vs '1'
                                                      .... organization Σ0..1Reference(Organization)This contact detail is handled/monitored by a specific organization
                                                      • Added this element
                                                      .... period Σ0..1PeriodPeriod that this contact was valid for usage
                                                      • Added this element
                                                      ... endpoint 0..*Reference(Endpoint)Technical endpoints providing access to services operated for the organization
                                                      0..*Reference(Endpoint)Technical endpoints providing access to services operated for the organization
                                                        ... description Σ0..1markdownAdditional details about the Organization that could be displayed as further information to identify the Organization beyond its name
                                                        • Added this element
                                                        ... qualification 0..*BackboneElementQualifications, certifications, accreditations, licenses, training, etc. pertaining to the provision of care
                                                        • Added this element

                                                        doco Documentation for this format